The wrong time and the wrong placeJun 1st, 2011 | By Ian Poulton | Category: Personal Columns
In the summer of 1987, we were on a campsite on France’s Loire Valley; Mesland comes to mind, but maybe it was somewhere else, no matter. Meeting people from Co Down, we agreed to meet for drinks that evening. At 9 o’clock, we gathered at their caravan and sat and talked for four hours, drinking glasses full of Pineau des Charentes, a fortified wine drunk normally as an aperitif. Amid the story telling and the laughter and the warmth of a French summer’s night, the Pineau seemed a perfect accompaniment. Buying a bottle at the local Intermarché seemed to offer the prospect of brightening up some evening in a Northern Ireland that was still in the midst of the Troubles with the taste of a French summer’s evening. It was December before the bottle was opened, a bleak month in bleak times, a friend called and we sat with a glass of the aperitif, ‘This is great stuff’, I said, ‘we bought it in the Loire last summer’. Of course, it wasn’t great, it didn’t taste at all like it had in the summer. In a different context, even tastes change.
Context seems everything, behaviour, words, thoughts even, seem dependent upon the particular context in which they are expressed. Attending regular rugby matches where crowds of up to 50,000 are common, there is an awareness that the context changes the situation; that fifteen players against fifteen players becomes a great drama played out on a field that is something far greater than a hundred metres of grass. The gathering of tens of thousands of people creates a dynamic that is simply not present when standing in a bar or sitting in the front room at home.
Attending church services in Africa, including one last year that ran from 9.30 am until 2.45 pm, there is a sense of the context giving a depth and a strength to the music that is not replicable in Ireland. The music might be repeated here, but it has not the edge, the urgency of the songs of those who live in the poorest places in the world. Standing in a two-roomed house in a poor district on the edge of a Rwandan town, the singing of the forty or so people crammed into a room has a mood that cannot be captured in European comfort and security.
Listening to John Creedon on RTE Radio 1 while driving through Co Laois, the thought occurs of whether I would ever think of listening to some of the music he plays if it were not for the fact that he was playing it at that moment. Not that any of it bad music, just that it doesn’t seem the same when it’s taken out of its setting. Maybe music more than anything depends on context. Tunes go with situations, taken out of context, they can seem odd, absurd even; like drinking Pineau des Charentes on an Ulster December evening.