From a distance – no-one's watching us

Apr 3rd, 2008 | By | Category: Ireland

Stories of aliens terrified me when I was a child. I hated Doctor Who with its daleks and cybermen. I hated stories of “flying saucers”. I once spent an evening avoiding a television version of War of the Worlds.

As the years have passed, the aliens have become an increasingly attractive option. If they have arrived here, their technology and knowledge is infinitely in advance of ours, and surely they would be more inspiring than the rulers of our world?

Contemplating the prospects for the new Irish Taoiseach, I wondered if the aliens had plans to arrive soon, only to have my hopes shattered on the DART this morning by reading Bill Bryson. Having lost my original copy of A Short History of Nearly Everything, I bought a new copy and in the opening pages was forced to abandon any notion that an alien intervention might save us from mediocrity.

Space, let me repeat, is enormous. The average distance between stars out there is over 30 million million kilo­metres. Even at speeds approaching those of light, these are fantastically challenging distances for any travelling individual. Of course, it is possible that alien beings travel billions of miles to amuse themselves by planting crop circles in Wiltshire or frightening the daylights out of some poor guy in a pickup truck on a lonely road in Arizona (they must have teenagers, after all), but it does seem unlikely.

Still, statistically the probability that there are other think­ing beings out there is good. Nobody knows how many stars there are in the Milky Way – estimates range from a hundred billion or so to perhaps four hundred billion – and the Milky Way is just one of a hundred and forty billion or so other galaxies, many of them even larger than ours. In the 1960s, a professor at Cornell named Frank Drake, excited by such whopping numbers, worked out a famous equation designed to calculate the chances of advanced life existing in the cosmos, based on a series of diminishing probabilities.

Under Drake’s equation you divide the number of stars in a selected portion of the universe by the number of stars that are. likely to have planetary systems; divide that by the number of planetary systems that could theoretically support life; divide that by the number on which life, having arisen, advances to a state of intelligence; and so on. At each such division, the number shrinks colossally – yet even with the most conservative inputs the number of advanced civilizations just in the Milky Way always works out to be somewhere in the millions.

What an interesting and exciting thought. We may be only one of millions of advanced civilizations. Unfortunately, space being spacious, the average distance between any two of these civilizations is reckoned to be at least two hundred light years, which is a great deal more than merely saying it makes it sound. It means, for a start, that even if these beings know we are here and are somehow able to see us in their telescopes, they’re watching light that left Earth two hundred years ago. So they’re not seeing you and me. They’re watching the French Revolution and Thomas Jefferson and people in silk stockings and powdered wigs ­– people who don’t know what an atom is, or a gene, and who make their electricity by rubbing a rod of amber with a piece of fur and think that’s quite a trick. Any message we receive from these observers is likely to begin ‘Dear Sire’, and congratulate us on the handsomeness of our horses and our mastery of whale oil. Two hundred light years is a distance so far beyond us as to be, well, just beyond us.

So even if we are not really alone, in all practical terms we are. Carl Sagan calculated the number of probable planets in the universe at as many as ten billion trillion – a number vastly beyond imagining. But what is equally beyond imagining is the amount of space through which they are lightly scattered. ‘If we were randomly inserted into the universe,’ Sagan wrote, ‘the chances that you would be on or near a planet would be less than one in a billion trillion trillion’.

A Short History of Nearly Everything, pp 48-49

What a depressing conclusion. Is there not a single extra-terrestrial out there who will rid us of these politicians?

Leave a comment »

  1. Haha . .he’s probably right but he didn’t factor in the old worm hole! How’s them eggs? hmmmm? Pop that in your stargate and jump to warp speed!

  2. Ian I could send over some of my ‘subbies’ I’m sure they are from another planet!!!!The brickies are proably the best contenders!!!

  3. Baino,

    Wormholes in space are theoretical, politicians, unfortunately, are not.


    I thought it was only builders’ trousers that operated outside the laws of time and space, I’m alarmed that it’s the entire builder who is from a different planet

  4. Might there not be unknown creatures living in the deep-sea trenches who could rise up and sort ou t the tax shortfall?:-)

  5. Alice,

    What an intriguing prospect – ten years on from the McCracken Tribunal, we could have the Kraken Tribunal.

  6. There is no control over the trousers, they are usually at least 2′ (or 600mm to the younger readers)from the brain!!! and their arms are too long to pull them up!!

Leave Comment